Golf legend Gary Player has reignited one of the sport’s oldest debates — who is the greatest golfer of all time — by boldly declaring himself the third-best player ever, ranking behind Jack Nicklaus and Tiger Woods.
In a recent interview, the 89-year-old South African didn’t hesitate when asked for his all-time list.
“Jack is number one, Tiger number two, and I’m number three,” Player said confidently. “There’s not even a question.”
According to Player, his ranking is based purely on records and statistics, not popularity or perception.
“How I judge the best players of all time is simple — I look at the record book. It’s the only thing that matters,” he said. “Jack Nicklaus has the best record. There’s no question about that.”
“Tiger Could Have Been the Greatest”
When addressing Tiger Woods’ place in history, Player acknowledged Woods’ extraordinary talent but argued that his off-course decisions ultimately cost him the top spot.
“If Tiger Woods had made the right choices, he would have been the greatest player that ever lived,” Player said. “But the worst saying in sport is if. Because if is immaterial. It’s the bottom line that counts.”
Woods, who underwent his seventh back surgery earlier this month, remains tied with Sam Snead for the most PGA Tour wins (82) and owns 15 major titles — three shy of Nicklaus’ record of 18.
“Arnold and Bobby Don’t Have My Record”
Player also took aim at how golf historians often place Arnold Palmer and Bobby Jones ahead of him on all-time lists.
“When they judge players, they put Bobby Jones and Arnold ahead of me,” he said. “You can’t tell me an amateur golfer has a record like mine. His record isn’t close to mine. Arnold’s isn’t either. I won more majors, more tournaments, more senior majors — and my scoring average was better.”
Despite that, Player emphasized his admiration for Palmer, calling him “my brother” and praising his impact on the game.
“I love that they put him up there, because what he did for golf was supreme,” he added.
A Legacy Built on Longevity
Player’s career statistics are staggering:
- 9 major championships — tied for third-most all time
- 24 PGA Tour wins in 449 starts
- Over 150 professional victories worldwide
- One of only five golfers to achieve the Career Grand Slam
Known as “The Black Knight,” Player’s influence on global golf remains unmatched. His career has spanned more than six decades, during which he became an ambassador for the sport’s worldwide growth.
Why Nicklaus Still Tops the List
In Player’s eyes, Jack Nicklaus’ record of 18 major wins and 19 runner-up finishes makes him untouchable.
“Jack’s record speaks for itself,” he said. “No one has matched that consistency in majors — not even Tiger.”
The Debate Rages On
Player’s remarks have reignited debate across the golf world. Many fans believe Tiger Woods’ dominance, cultural impact, and athleticism still make him the greatest ever, while others agree with Player that Nicklaus’ record remains the ultimate standard.
Either way, Gary Player’s self-assured ranking — and his unfiltered honesty — prove that even at 89, the three-time Masters champion is still as competitive as ever.
Leave a Reply